Mourning Twice

imagesCAAHRQWL  “Well then,” Rabbi Straus counseled, “you’ll need to give yourself permission to mourn twice.”

The rabbi was new to our congregation, and I hadn’t met him yet; we were talking by phone.  “Mourn twice?”

“Once for the mother you had, and once for the mother you didn’t have.”

I’d just told Rabbi Straus that my mom was under hospice care and was unlikely to last much longer.  And I’d provided him with a brief background:  Mom was not a nurturer; she was difficult, and had caused her children a lot of suffering.  With her death imminent, I’d felt some urgency about pre-empting any assumptions Rabbi Straus might make about Mom.  I couldn’t bear to hear anything resembling a mother’s love is unconditional.

When I level with someone about my mother, I’m always a little startled to be believed.  Somehow, I expect a lecture:  surely she meant well; shouldn’t I have moved on by now, forgiven her?

And because my three sisters and I are very close with one another and have been so devoted to Mom, the claim that Mom was destructive or disturbed is bound to confuse.  She can’t have been that bad—you all turned out so well! runs the cheery skepticism.

She was that bad.  But when do I make the case, and when do I let it go?  If I smile and let things roll off my back, I feel I’m in some way complicit in the abuse and rejection that my sisters and I survived.  If I try to set the record straight, I worry that I sound shrill or not credible.

Mom died on August 2nd, and shortly afterward I spoke candidly with an elderly relative.  “Your parents treated you girls horribly,” she told me.  She also observed that Mom “lost interest” in us once we grew out of babyhood.  I was infinitely grateful for this validation, as I was when Mom’s physician reported that my mother had several previously undiagnosed psychiatric conditions as well as dementia.

I know this will sound odd, but lately I’ve been haunted by my own generosity toward Mom.  Why did my sisters and I move her back here nine years ago?  (Tellingly, she’d opted to relocate from Berkeley to New York just as my sister and I were starting families in the Bay Area.)  Why did we obsess over hiring only the most loving caregivers for her, include her in seders, bring her to the kids’ recitals?  Why the spontaneous Happy Birthday medley we sang at her bedside on her 89th birthday, just eleven days before she died?

What is the world supposed to think of those acts, but that they were the natural outgrowth of a wonderful relationship?

What I’ve begun to realize since Mom died is how humiliated I’d always felt by the way she treated me—how deeply, if irrationally, ashamed.  By integrating Mom into our loving families, my sisters and I were rewriting our story, joining the community of adults concerned about aging parents.  We couldn’t have the real thing, but at least we’d fashion a soothing retrofit.  It was what we could do.

One painful aspect of losing Mom is the use of phrases like “your beloved mother” in some of the many well-meaning cards and e-mails I’ve received.  It’s been an important part of my mourning process to thank each person in writing—with honesty.

Mom was a difficult person, I explain, and the challenge for me now is to sort through some very complicated feelings.  I greatly appreciate the support of community at this painful time.

I know my rabbi is behind me on this.

Published in the Piedmont Post, September 7, 2011

Please visit  Thanks!

Tags: , , , ,

6 Responses to “Mourning Twice”

  1. Michele Says:

    Kudos to your rabbi for getting it. I’m glad (sad) that at long last, you feel validation by both your older relative’s observation and the reasons provided by your mother’s doctor, for what you and your sisters have endured over the years.

    You put a terribly complicated, emotionally devastating piece of your life into very clear terms in this essay– as usual, lightened by your humor– i. e., the “cheery skepticism” expressed by those who observe how well you and your sisters have turned out.

    How you and your sisters turned out is indeed remarkable.

  2. melissa Says:

    There’s the brave in Braver. Honest and forthright, a comfort to many who cannot give words to their similar feelings about a parent.

  3. bonnie burt Says:

    I’m always impressed – as opposed to: I’m Not Impressed- by your honesty and ability to tackle difficult subjects with subtlety and nuance. I’m happy to know that you are feeling more validated during this complex time of sorting things out.

  4. nina Says:

    Your honesty and hard-won insights are a service to the rest of us. Thank you for doing that.

  5. Elisa B Says:

    Your mother was not the mother that you should have had, but the four of you were the kind of daughters that a good mother would have loved to have. By raising your own children in a loving way and by taking care of your mother despite her hurtful behavior, you created your own better legacy. All of you should be proud of your generosity. It’s much easier to show compassion for somebody who is kind. What you did was extraordinarily difficult.

  6. Gini Carterr Says:

    LISA, what a great testament to your own courage and sense of soul. I’m sure you will get some “bravo” comments from the community. This is one. Many people never get to the place of true honesty about such horrors. I believe this is a necessary step towards any healing that may be had. I think your writing will help anyone paying attention to move forward in their own reconciliation of parental abuse. Thanks for this strong and important message!!!

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: